Does the Social Energy Tariff Reach Energy-Poor Households? A Municipal Framework for Assessing Hidden Winter and Summer Energy Poverty in Portugal

Does the Social Energy Tariff Reach Energy-Poor Households? A Municipal Framework for Assessing Hidden Winter and Summer Energy Poverty in Portugal

ES评分 0

DOI 10.20900/jsr20260078
刊名
JSR
年,卷(期) 2026, 8(3)
作者
作者单位

proMetheus, Research Unit on Energy, Materials and Environment for Sustainability, Instituto Politécnico de Viana do Castelo

摘要
Although Portugal enjoys a temperate climate by European standards, it records some of the highest levels of self-reported thermal discomfort in the European Union: in 2024, 15.7% of the resident population declared being financially unable to keep the home adequately warm, compared with an EU-27 average of 9.2%, while 29.9% reported being unable to keep the dwelling comfortably cool during the summer. This article argues that conventional energy-poverty metrics, based on expenditure shares or on arrears, are poorly suited to this reality, since many households respond to unaffordable energy by restricting consumption below the level required for thermal comfort, a phenomenon known as hidden energy poverty that remains invisible to expenditure-based statistics. Portugal’s principal protective instrument, the Social Energy Tariff, has been assigned automatically since 2016 on income and social-benefit criteria and covered approximately 775,000 electricity clients in the third quarter of 2025, yet its territorial correspondence with the geography of energy deprivation has never been systematically evaluated. The article therefore develops a municipal, spatiotemporal framework in which economic vulnerability, dwelling-stock vulnerability, climatic exposure, and an underconsumption indicator derived from administrative electricity records are integrated into a latent Hidden Energy Poverty Index, estimated with Bayesian spatiotemporal methods for the 308 Portuguese municipalities over 2016–2024. The framework distinguishes winter from summer vulnerability, quantifies municipal gaps between estimated need and tariff coverage, and pre-specifies a quasi-experimental test of the tariff’s protective role during the 2021–2023 price shock, with descriptive evidence from official statistics supporting its premises. The framework is additionally implemented in reduced form with published data: a cross-national regression for the EU-27 confirms that dwelling-stock quality predicts thermal deprivation conditional on income; the structural core of the index is computed for the twenty-four NUTS III subregions of mainland Portugal, revealing distinct climatic geographies of winter and summer vulnerability bridged by a socially vulnerable interior belt; and the published territorial footprint of the tariff is shown to track winter need while leaving the geography of summer need comparatively unprotected.
Abstract
Although Portugal enjoys a temperate climate by European standards, it records some of the highest levels of self-reported thermal discomfort in the European Union: in 2024, 15.7% of the resident population declared being financially unable to keep the home adequately warm, compared with an EU-27 average of 9.2%, while 29.9% reported being unable to keep the dwelling comfortably cool during the summer. This article argues that conventional energy-poverty metrics, based on expenditure shares or on arrears, are poorly suited to this reality, since many households respond to unaffordable energy by restricting consumption below the level required for thermal comfort, a phenomenon known as hidden energy poverty that remains invisible to expenditure-based statistics. Portugal’s principal protective instrument, the Social Energy Tariff, has been assigned automatically since 2016 on income and social-benefit criteria and covered approximately 775,000 electricity clients in the third quarter of 2025, yet its territorial correspondence with the geography of energy deprivation has never been systematically evaluated. The article therefore develops a municipal, spatiotemporal framework in which economic vulnerability, dwelling-stock vulnerability, climatic exposure, and an underconsumption indicator derived from administrative electricity records are integrated into a latent Hidden Energy Poverty Index, estimated with Bayesian spatiotemporal methods for the 308 Portuguese municipalities over 2016–2024. The framework distinguishes winter from summer vulnerability, quantifies municipal gaps between estimated need and tariff coverage, and pre-specifies a quasi-experimental test of the tariff’s protective role during the 2021–2023 price shock, with descriptive evidence from official statistics supporting its premises. The framework is additionally implemented in reduced form with published data: a cross-national regression for the EU-27 confirms that dwelling-stock quality predicts thermal deprivation conditional on income; the structural core of the index is computed for the twenty-four NUTS III subregions of mainland Portugal, revealing distinct climatic geographies of winter and summer vulnerability bridged by a socially vulnerable interior belt; and the published territorial footprint of the tariff is shown to track winter need while leaving the geography of summer need comparatively unprotected.
关键词
energy poverty; hidden energy poverty; underconsumption; social tariff; thermal comfort; spatial analysis
KeyWord
energy poverty; hidden energy poverty; underconsumption; social tariff; thermal comfort; spatial analysis
基金项目
页码 -
  • 参考文献
  • 相关文献
  • 引用本文

Leonel J. R. Nunes. Does the Social Energy Tariff Reach Energy-Poor Households? A Municipal Framework for Assessing Hidden Winter and Summer Energy Poverty in Portugal [J]. Journal of Sustainability Research. 2026; 8; (3). - .

  • 文献评论

相关学者

相关机构