Identifying Critical Issues Associated with the Sustainability of Controlled Environment Agriculture: A Delphi Analysis

Identifying Critical Issues Associated with the Sustainability of Controlled Environment Agriculture: A Delphi Analysis

ES评分 0

DOI 10.20900/jsr20260049
刊名
JSR
年,卷(期) 2026, 8(2)
作者
作者单位

Biosystems Engineering, Auburn University, Auburn, AL 36849, USA Department of Agricultural Leadership, Education & Communication, University of Georgia, Athens, GA 30602, USA Educational Foundations, Leadership, and Technology, College of Education, Auburn University, Auburn, AL 36849, USA

摘要
Achieving sustainable food production in the context of geographic, climatic, and resource constraints remains a complex and wicked problem. In response to geographic constraints in growing fruits, vegetables, ornamentals, and other weather sensitive crops, some have suggested that greenhouse and indoor farming, popularly known as controlled environment agriculture (CEA), may offer the opportunity to increase food production and off-season access to fresh produce. However, despite the potential for CEA to address many of the challenges associated with conventional, geographic constrained, food production, several limitations and critical issues associated with the long-term sustainability of CEA persist. Therefore, the present study, conducted in collaboration with a panel of CEA experts, compiled a comprehensive list of critical issues facing the CEA industry using the Delphi methodology. Using a three-round consensus-building process, 30 critical issues were identified, with seven items receiving 100% agreement among the panelists, including sales price of crops, profitability, labor costs, finding markets, energy costs, cost of production, and cost effectiveness. The final list of items was then organized into themes within the retained items. Eight primary themes emerged including (alphabetically): disease and pests, energy, economic considerations, food safety and quality, market dynamics, operation and infrastructure, startup capital, and workforce. The proposed themes and subsumed critical issues represent a heuristic framework to facilitate dialogue, prioritize sustainability-related issues, target investments, and where appropriate, refine policy and regulations to support sustainable CEA adoption.
Abstract
Achieving sustainable food production in the context of geographic, climatic, and resource constraints remains a complex and wicked problem. In response to geographic constraints in growing fruits, vegetables, ornamentals, and other weather sensitive crops, some have suggested that greenhouse and indoor farming, popularly known as controlled environment agriculture (CEA), may offer the opportunity to increase food production and off-season access to fresh produce. However, despite the potential for CEA to address many of the challenges associated with conventional, geographic constrained, food production, several limitations and critical issues associated with the long-term sustainability of CEA persist. Therefore, the present study, conducted in collaboration with a panel of CEA experts, compiled a comprehensive list of critical issues facing the CEA industry using the Delphi methodology. Using a three-round consensus-building process, 30 critical issues were identified, with seven items receiving 100% agreement among the panelists, including sales price of crops, profitability, labor costs, finding markets, energy costs, cost of production, and cost effectiveness. The final list of items was then organized into themes within the retained items. Eight primary themes emerged including (alphabetically): disease and pests, energy, economic considerations, food safety and quality, market dynamics, operation and infrastructure, startup capital, and workforce. The proposed themes and subsumed critical issues represent a heuristic framework to facilitate dialogue, prioritize sustainability-related issues, target investments, and where appropriate, refine policy and regulations to support sustainable CEA adoption.
关键词
controlled environment agriculture; sustainable food systems; sustainability; critical issues; Delphi method; consensus building
KeyWord
controlled environment agriculture; sustainable food systems; sustainability; critical issues; Delphi method; consensus building
基金项目
页码 -
  • 参考文献
  • 相关文献
  • 引用本文

Alexa J. Lamm, Andrews Idun, Brendan Higgins, Jessica Holt, Kevan W. Lamm, MiHee Park. Identifying Critical Issues Associated with the Sustainability of Controlled Environment Agriculture: A Delphi Analysis [J]. Journal of Sustainability Research. 2026; 8; (2). - .

  • 文献评论

相关学者

相关机构