Space Efficiency as a Method-Dependent Construct: Evidence from High-Rise Timber Buildings

Space Efficiency as a Method-Dependent Construct: Evidence from High-Rise Timber Buildings

ES评分 0

DOI 10.20900/jsr20260048
刊名
JSR
年,卷(期) 2026, 8(2)
作者
作者单位

School of Architecture, Faculty of Built Environment, Tampere University, FI-33014 Tampere, Finland

摘要
Space efficiency is widely employed as a key performance indicator in high-rise (≥8-story) building research, typically expressed through net-to-gross floor area (NFA/GFA) ratios and core-related metrics. In high-rise timber construction, such indicators are frequently used to compare architectural forms, core configurations, structural systems, and material strategies, often under the implicit assumption that they reflect intrinsic design performance. Although previous studies have documented a relatively narrow range of reported NFA/GFA values, the methodological implications of this convergence have not been systematically examined. This study reconceptualizes space efficiency as a method-dependent analytical construct rather than an objective performance outcome. Using a qualitative meta-interpretive approach, an internally consistent dataset of 79 high-rise timber buildings is re-examined to assess distributional overlap, dispersion patterns, and range compression across architectural, structural, and material categories, without recalculating the original metrics. The analysis demonstrates that the observed convergence of efficiency values is more plausibly attributable to metric construction, definitional alignment, and typical floor standardization than to substantive design equivalence. Limited between-category separation and substantial interquartile overlap indicate that conventional space efficiency ratios possess restricted discriminatory capacity within a uniform measurement framework. These findings reposition space efficiency metrics as conditional analytical tools whose interpretive validity depends on methodological transparency. Greater caution is therefore warranted in the comparative and evaluative use of efficiency ratios in high-rise timber building research and practice.
Abstract
Space efficiency is widely employed as a key performance indicator in high-rise (≥8-story) building research, typically expressed through net-to-gross floor area (NFA/GFA) ratios and core-related metrics. In high-rise timber construction, such indicators are frequently used to compare architectural forms, core configurations, structural systems, and material strategies, often under the implicit assumption that they reflect intrinsic design performance. Although previous studies have documented a relatively narrow range of reported NFA/GFA values, the methodological implications of this convergence have not been systematically examined. This study reconceptualizes space efficiency as a method-dependent analytical construct rather than an objective performance outcome. Using a qualitative meta-interpretive approach, an internally consistent dataset of 79 high-rise timber buildings is re-examined to assess distributional overlap, dispersion patterns, and range compression across architectural, structural, and material categories, without recalculating the original metrics. The analysis demonstrates that the observed convergence of efficiency values is more plausibly attributable to metric construction, definitional alignment, and typical floor standardization than to substantive design equivalence. Limited between-category separation and substantial interquartile overlap indicate that conventional space efficiency ratios possess restricted discriminatory capacity within a uniform measurement framework. These findings reposition space efficiency metrics as conditional analytical tools whose interpretive validity depends on methodological transparency. Greater caution is therefore warranted in the comparative and evaluative use of efficiency ratios in high-rise timber building research and practice.
关键词
space efficiency metrics; high-rise timber buildings; sustainable building design; measurement methodology; comparative building analysis
KeyWord
space efficiency metrics; high-rise timber buildings; sustainable building design; measurement methodology; comparative building analysis
基金项目
页码 -
  • 参考文献
  • 相关文献
  • 引用本文

Hüseyin Emre Ilgın. Space Efficiency as a Method-Dependent Construct: Evidence from High-Rise Timber Buildings [J]. Journal of Sustainability Research. 2026; 8; (2). - .

  • 文献评论

相关学者

相关机构