BDS-3与GPS的长期定位精度对比

Comparion of BDS-3 and GPS Positioning Accuracy across Spatial Scales

ES评分 0

DOI 10.14075/j.jgg.2025.11.367
刊名
Journal of Geodesy and Geodynamics
年,卷(期) 2026, 46(7)
作者
作者单位

1 中国地震局地震研究所,武汉,430071;
2 中国地震局地震大地测量重点实验室,武汉,430071;
3 中国地震台网中心,北京,100045

摘要
为评估BDS-3性能并推动其应用优化,基于GAMIT/GLOBK 10.71软件处理2023年DOY001—2025年DOY067全球56个IGS站点及中国大陆50个基准站的长时段数据,从模糊度固定率、卫星轨道精度、坐标时间序列和速度场4个维度,对比分析BDS-3与GPS在全球及区域尺度下的长期定位精度。结果表明,BDS-3在全球网中的窄巷模糊度固定率均值(72.7%)低于GPS(88.1%),但在区域网中表现更优(BDS-3为80.1%,GPS为76.2%)。卫星轨道精度方面,BDS-3的轨道积分残差参数平均高于GPS约1.5~2.8 mm。坐标时间序列分析表明,BDS-3在N、E、U方向的坐标时间序列平均WRMS值(2.44 mm、2.8 mm、7.0 mm)高于GPS(1.7 mm、1.8 mm、5.7 mm),且U方向离散度更大,但速度场比较显示,两者一致性较高(90%站点速率差在1 mm/a以内)。研究表明,BDS-3在区域尺度定位性能接近GPS,但全球精度和稳定性仍需提升,未来需加强模型、算法优化和多系统融合研究。
Abstract
To assess the performance of BDS-3 and promote its application optimization, this study processed long-term observation data from 56 global IGS stations and 50 reference stations in mainland China from DOY 001, 2023 to DOY 067, 2025 using the GAMIT/GLOBK 10.71 software. The long-term positioning accuracy of BDS-3 and GPS was compared and analyzed at both global and regional scales across four dimensions: ambiguity fixed rate, satellite orbit accuracy, coordinate time series, and velocity field. The results indicate that the average narrow-lane ambiguity fixed rate of BDS-3 in the global network (72.7%) is lower than that of GPS (88.1%), but it performs better in the regional network (BDS-3: 80.1%, GPS: 76.2%). In terms of satellite orbit accuracy, the orbit integration residuals of BDS-3 are on average 1.5—2.8 mm higher than those of GPS. Analysis of coordinate time series shows that the average WRMS values for BDS-3 in the N, E, and U directions (2.44 mm, 2.8 mm, 7.0 mm) are higher than those of GPS (1.7 mm, 1.8 mm, 5.7 mm), with greater dispersion in the vertical direction. However, comparison of the velocity fields reveals a high consistency between the two systems (90% of stations exhibit rate differences within 1 mm/a). The study demonstrates that the positioning performance of BDS-3 at the regional scale is close to that of GPS, but its global accuracy and stability still require improvement. Future efforts should focus on enhancing models, optimizing algorithms, and advancing research on multi-system integration.
关键词
BDS-3; GPS; 定位精度; 全球尺度; 区域尺度
KeyWord
BDS-3; GPS; positioning accuracy; global scales; regional scales
基金项目
页码 790-797
  • 参考文献
  • 相关文献
  • 引用本文

王东振, 赵斌, 王阅兵, 林牧, 余建胜. BDS-3与GPS的长期定位精度对比 [J]. 大地测量与地球动力学. 2026; 46; (7). 790 - 797.

  • 文献评论

相关学者

相关机构