200例刑事责任能力鉴定案例分析

Analysis of 200 Cases which Have Criminal Responsibility of Forensic Psychiatric Assessment

ES评分 0

DOI
刊名
Journal of International Psychiatry
年,卷(期) 2018, 45(5)
作者
作者单位

芜湖市第四人民医院 ;

摘要
探讨安徽芜湖地区刑事责任能力评定案件的特点及一般规律,为精神障碍患者的防控工作及预防违法犯罪行为提供一些参考数据。方法 采用自制信息采集表,对2013年9月至2016年11月在安徽昌平司法鉴定所实施刑事责任能力评定的案件200例进行资料收集。结果 200例刑事案件中,男性占85%,平均年龄(36.60±13.18)岁,16~45岁占75.5%。初中及以下文化程度占85%,未婚及离异者占58%,无业及农民占83.5%。作案类型中,涉嫌盗窃所占比例最高,为30.5%,其次为故意伤害(27.0%),故意杀人仅占9.0%。鉴定诊断前5位依次是情感性精神障碍(28.5%)、精神分裂症(21.5%)、精神发育迟滞(20.0%)、无精神病(13.5%)和器质性精神障碍(5.5%)。鉴定意见为完全刑事责任能力最多,占43.5%,限定刑事责任能力所占比例最少,为26.0%。结论 安徽芜湖地区刑事责任能力评定的案件中,以青壮年男性、低文化程度、未婚的无业人员及农民为主。鉴定诊断前5位的是情感性精神障碍、精神分裂症、精神发育迟滞、无精神病和器质性精神障碍。
Abstract
Objective Discuss the characteristics and ordinary rules of cases which have criminal responsibility of forensic psychiatric assessment in Wuhu, Anhui Province, providing reference data for preventing, controlling work of patients with mental disorders and preventing criminal acts. Methods The information of 200 cases was collected which were under criminal responsibility assessment in Anhui Changping Institute of Forensic Science from September 2013 to November 2016 using self-made information collection table. Results Out of 200 criminal cases, 170 cases (85%) were male, the average age was (36.60±13.18), 151 cases (75.5%) were between 16 and 45 years old. 170 cases (85%) were graduated from junior middle school and below. 116 cases (58%) were unmarried or divorced. 167 cases (83.5%) were unemployed and peasants. Among all the types of criminals, there were suspected thieves (30.5%), followed by who committed intentional injury (27.0%), and the ones who committed intentional homicide only account 9.0%. After the diagnosis, the affective disorders(28.5%), Schizophrenia(21.5%), mental retardation(20.0%), without psychosis(13.5%) and organic mental disorders(5.5%) were the top five kinds of factors contribute to criminal acts. Full criminal responsibility (43.5%) occupied the highest proportion, and diminished criminal responsibility (26.0%) occupied the least proportion. Conclusions Most of the suspects of criminal responsibility were male young adult with low level of education, unmarried, peasants and unemployed in Wuhu, Anhui Province. The top five factors diagnosed were affective disorders, schizophrenia, mental retardation, without psychosis and organic mental disorders.
关键词
司法精神病鉴定;刑事案件;刑事责任能力
KeyWord
Forensic psychiatry; Criminal case; Criminal responsibility
基金项目
页码 888-891
  • 参考文献
  • 相关文献
  • 引用本文

丁红艳*. 200例刑事责任能力鉴定案例分析 [J]. 国际精神病学杂志. 2018; 45; (5). 888 - 891.

  • 文献评论

相关学者

相关机构