Transcultural Psychiatry and Neuroimaging: A 2 × 2 Factorial Framework for Culturally Anchored Study Designs

Transcultural Psychiatry and Neuroimaging: A 2 × 2 Factorial Framework for Culturally Anchored Study Designs

ES评分 0

DOI 10.20900/jpbs.20260016
刊名
JPBS
年,卷(期) 2026, 11(5)
作者
作者单位

Department of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, Medical University of Vienna, 1090 Vienna, Austria

摘要
Psychiatric neuroimaging seeks to identify neural mechanisms of mental disorders and frequently interprets its findings as biologically grounded and potentially universal. However, transcultural psychiatry has consistently shown that symptom expression, illness meaning, and clinical course vary systematically across cultural contexts. At the same time, cultural neuroscience demonstrates that neural organization itself—particularly in domains such as self-related processing and emotion regulation—can be modulated by culturally structured experience. These insights challenge a central but often implicit assumption of psychiatric neuroimaging: that neural baselines are culturally neutral. Most cross-national imaging studies either rely on case–control comparisons within a single setting or compare patient groups across countries without locally anchored control groups. In such designs, culturally patterned baseline variation cannot be distinguished from disorder-specific neural alterations. This review integrates empirical findings from transcultural psychiatry and cultural neuroscience and argues that the key limitation of current cross-cultural neuroimaging lies in study architecture rather than analytic sophistication. We argue that a 2 × 2 factorial design, with patient and healthy control groups recruited within each sociocultural setting, provides a minimal framework for estimating disorder effects, contextual baseline effects, and context × disorder interactions without assuming that the grouping factor itself constitutes a complete measure of culture. By making cultural baselines empirically explicit, psychiatric neuroimaging can move from implicit universalism toward methodologically grounded global validity.
Abstract
Psychiatric neuroimaging seeks to identify neural mechanisms of mental disorders and frequently interprets its findings as biologically grounded and potentially universal. However, transcultural psychiatry has consistently shown that symptom expression, illness meaning, and clinical course vary systematically across cultural contexts. At the same time, cultural neuroscience demonstrates that neural organization itself—particularly in domains such as self-related processing and emotion regulation—can be modulated by culturally structured experience. These insights challenge a central but often implicit assumption of psychiatric neuroimaging: that neural baselines are culturally neutral. Most cross-national imaging studies either rely on case–control comparisons within a single setting or compare patient groups across countries without locally anchored control groups. In such designs, culturally patterned baseline variation cannot be distinguished from disorder-specific neural alterations. This review integrates empirical findings from transcultural psychiatry and cultural neuroscience and argues that the key limitation of current cross-cultural neuroimaging lies in study architecture rather than analytic sophistication. We argue that a 2 × 2 factorial design, with patient and healthy control groups recruited within each sociocultural setting, provides a minimal framework for estimating disorder effects, contextual baseline effects, and context × disorder interactions without assuming that the grouping factor itself constitutes a complete measure of culture. By making cultural baselines empirically explicit, psychiatric neuroimaging can move from implicit universalism toward methodologically grounded global validity.
关键词
transcultural psychiatry; psychiatric neuroimaging; cultural neuroscience; cross-cultural research; 2 × 2 factorial design; neural baselines; schizophrenia; depression; PTSD; global mental health
KeyWord
transcultural psychiatry; psychiatric neuroimaging; cultural neuroscience; cross-cultural research; 2 × 2 factorial design; neural baselines; schizophrenia; depression; PTSD; global mental health
基金项目
页码 -
  • 参考文献
  • 相关文献
  • 引用本文

Thomas Stompe. Transcultural Psychiatry and Neuroimaging: A 2 × 2 Factorial Framework for Culturally Anchored Study Designs [J]. Journal of Psychiatry and Brain Science. 2026; 11; (5). - .

  • 文献评论

相关学者

相关机构