Harmonization of Surface Water Quality Assessment Methods in Central Asia: Contemporary Approaches and Emerging Challenges

Harmonization of Surface Water Quality Assessment Methods in Central Asia: Contemporary Approaches and Emerging Challenges

ES评分 0

DOI 10.20900/jsr20260039
刊名
JSR
年,卷(期) 2026, 8(2)
作者
作者单位

Department Meteorology and Climatology, Tajik National University, Dushanbe 734025, TajikistanDepartment of Ecology and Subsoil Use, JSC Qarmet, Temirtau 101407, KazakhstanDepartment of Geography and Ecology, Institute of Natural Sciences, Kyrgyz State University, Arabaev, Bishkek 720026, KyrgyzstanDepartment of Meteorology and Hydrology, Al-Farabi Kazakh National University, Almaty 050010, KazakhstanDepartment of Operation of Irrigation and Melioration Systems, Institute of Irrigation and Agricultural Mechanization Engineers, Tashkent 100000, UzbekistanDepartment of UNESCO Chair on Sustainable Development, Al-Farabi Kazakh National University, Almaty 050010, KazakhstanFaculty of Geography, Philipps-Universität Marburg, D-35032 Marburg, GermanyInstituto de Ingeniería del Agua y del Medio Ambiente (IIAMA), Universitat Politècnica de València, 46022 Valencia, SpainJSC Institute of Geography and Water Security, Almaty 050010, KazakhstanState Key Laboratory of Lake and Watershed Science for Water Security, Nanjing Institute of Geography and Limnology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Nanjing 211135, China

摘要
A first-time comparative scientific literature analysis of monitoring and assessing the surface water quality in five Central Asian (CA) countries (Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, and Uzbekistan) was carried out. The methodological approaches, surface water quality parameter, pollution indices and state acts in CA countries were compared, and benchmarked against international frameworks and practices (e.g., those of the EU, USA, and Canada). The methodological framework of the study based on a comparative analytical review of regulatory and methodological documents, official reports of national hydrometeorological services, and international guidelines. The comparison was conducted using standardized criteria (assessment logic, classification systems, quality indices, parameter coverage, monitoring organization, Quality Assurance/Quality Control (QA/QC) procedures, and transboundary comparability). The analysis reveals the emergence of three distinct developmental trajectories of water quality assessment methodologies in the region: a modernization pathway (Kazakhstan), a transitional/hybrid pathway (Uzbekistan), and an approach preserving the post-Soviet methodological architecture (Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, and Turkmenistan). A phased harmonization plan is proposed, taking into account the natural background characteristics of arid basins and prioritizing the comparability of transboundary water quality data. Significant discrepancies between approaches are highlighted. These range from differences in the calculation of composite water pollution indices (e.g., the Water Pollution Index—WPI) and biological indices (e.g., saprobe indices), to inconsistencies in sampling frequency and methods, as well as in the classification of pollution categories. The analysis reveals that the disparity in methodologies hinders the comparability of water quality data even for transboundary rivers, leading to potential disputes between states. The study substantiates the need for harmonizing of water monitoring and assessment approaches, drawing on successful international standards (e.g., the EU Water Framework Directive, US EPA methods, and the CCME WQI). A concept for a unified surface water quality assessment system tailored to the Central Asian region, which accounts for local environmental, sanitary, and political-legal conditions, is proposed.
Abstract
A first-time comparative scientific literature analysis of monitoring and assessing the surface water quality in five Central Asian (CA) countries (Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, and Uzbekistan) was carried out. The methodological approaches, surface water quality parameter, pollution indices and state acts in CA countries were compared, and benchmarked against international frameworks and practices (e.g., those of the EU, USA, and Canada). The methodological framework of the study based on a comparative analytical review of regulatory and methodological documents, official reports of national hydrometeorological services, and international guidelines. The comparison was conducted using standardized criteria (assessment logic, classification systems, quality indices, parameter coverage, monitoring organization, Quality Assurance/Quality Control (QA/QC) procedures, and transboundary comparability). The analysis reveals the emergence of three distinct developmental trajectories of water quality assessment methodologies in the region: a modernization pathway (Kazakhstan), a transitional/hybrid pathway (Uzbekistan), and an approach preserving the post-Soviet methodological architecture (Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, and Turkmenistan). A phased harmonization plan is proposed, taking into account the natural background characteristics of arid basins and prioritizing the comparability of transboundary water quality data. Significant discrepancies between approaches are highlighted. These range from differences in the calculation of composite water pollution indices (e.g., the Water Pollution Index—WPI) and biological indices (e.g., saprobe indices), to inconsistencies in sampling frequency and methods, as well as in the classification of pollution categories. The analysis reveals that the disparity in methodologies hinders the comparability of water quality data even for transboundary rivers, leading to potential disputes between states. The study substantiates the need for harmonizing of water monitoring and assessment approaches, drawing on successful international standards (e.g., the EU Water Framework Directive, US EPA methods, and the CCME WQI). A concept for a unified surface water quality assessment system tailored to the Central Asian region, which accounts for local environmental, sanitary, and political-legal conditions, is proposed.
关键词
ecology; harmonization; methods; water quality; pollution; classification system
KeyWord
ecology; harmonization; methods; water quality; pollution; classification system
基金项目
页码 -
  • 参考文献
  • 相关文献
  • 引用本文

Aidar Zhumalipov, Anvar Sherov, Arai Sultanayeva, Askhat Zhadi, Azamat Madibekov, Botakoz Sultanbekova, Christian Opp, Inom Normatov, Javier Rodrigo-Ilarri, Kundyz Nakysbekova, Laura Ismukhanova, María-Elena Rodrigo-Clavero, Temirbek Chodurayev, Yermek Umarov, Zhonghua Zhao. Harmonization of Surface Water Quality Assessment Methods in Central Asia: Contemporary Approaches and Emerging Challenges [J]. Journal of Sustainability Research. 2026; 8; (2). - .

  • 文献评论

相关学者

相关机构